Devastating Economic and Community Impacts of Buy-and-Dry in Colorado’s Lower Arkansas Valley Documented in New Interactive Website

EDITOR’S PREFACE TO NEWS RELEASE:   I spoke with Jack Goble, General Manager of the Lower Ark District, on November 19 regarding the following press release. He said the District is amping up their published social media information to help educate the public about what is happening with water in our region. We discussed the prevalence of “Buy and dry” deals, which are becoming more and more common and are basically a Catch-22 for local farmers.  Drought is a major factor – when farmers can’t irrigate their crops, production drops or ceases and the prospect of receiving money for their water rights can be too tempting for some to ignore.  Having to choose between feeding their families and paying their bills and selling water rights is a tough decision.  The result from these sales is a significant loss in economic output for the communities those farms are part of.  The past several months have also seen huge increases in diesel costs which is crippling many farmers.  Everything from tractors working the land to trucks transporting crops and vegetables to market rely on diesel to operate.  Adding the soaring costs of fertilizer creates a perfect storm for farmers having to make this choice.

“Water is the lifeblood of our communities here,” Goble said, in reference to the need to keep as much water in the region as possible for many reasons.  “We need to look beyond economics  and also consider wildlife and their habitats, our history and heritage”. He said they are having conversations with other conservation districts in the state regarding “What we want Colorado agriculture to look like in the future”.  He also mentioned the need for a new federal Farm Bill – one which helps irrigated farms and water rights.  We also discussed the hot topic of data centers and water usage.  A proposed data center in Elbert County east of Colorado Springs has recently been in the news, as County Commissioners there are weighing a rezoning request for the proposed “Colorado Plains Ranch Data Center”  – a planned 5,700 campus housing 5 buildings producing 540 megawatts.  Recently, those commissioners postponed a vote until a December 9 meeting.  The development would hold rights to groundwater beneath it and be allowed to use about 60 million gallons a year and use a closed-loop cooling system using 500,00 gallons of “imported water” for the initial phase rather than water from Denver aquifers.

Sources outside Colorado also pose a risk to Arkansas Valley water.  Select Water Solutions, a Texas-based company, announced a strategic investment of $62 million to expand into the municipal and industrial water markets in Colorado.  Per the Lower Ark District website, “Select Water Solutions, Inc., a $1.5 billion, Texas-based company traded on the New York Stock Exchange (WTTR), has purchased a 35% stake in AV Farms, LP for $62 million. AV Farms, LP was recently formed through the consolidation of 10 other companies owned, in part, by Karl Nyquist and C&A Companies out of Englewood, CO.  AV Farms’ assets include significant land and water assets under the Fort Lyon Canal and Lamar Canal companies, as well as 5,324 shares in the Lower Arkansas Water Management Association (LAWMA). At an investor conference in March, Select Water Solutions revealed their plans for this investment, stating: “By 2050, the Arkansas River Basin within Colorado, which supports the southern Denver and Colorado Springs metro areas, is expected to have a ~50-100k acre-feet gap in supply annually. …Multiple municipal water buyers with projected demand gaps identified, including near term visibility into demand in excess of 50k AF that is a fit for this asset. They further outline plans to contribute up to an additional $84 million for acquiring water rights and developing infrastructure, contingent upon securing long-term contracts. In doing so, we anticipate transitioning to a majority (~56%+) ownership position over time. 

I highly encourage readers to watch the video on the new interactive website listed below.  It gives an intimate look at how these issues are affecting local farms.

 

PRESS RELEASE:

On November 4, 2026, the Lower Arkansas Valley Water Conservancy District (Lower Ark District) today announced the release of a first-of-its-kind interactive website, When Water Leaves: The Story of Buy-and-Dry in Colorado’s Lower Arkansas Valley, which examines the lasting consequences of agricultural water exports on the Lower Arkansas Valley’s farmland, economy, and communities.  The website, known as a StoryMap, is now available to the public at whenwaterleaves.com.

The StoryMap traces the history of the Lower Arkansas Valley, exploring how communities took root and prospered as irrigation canals brought Arkansas River water to farmland. Through historical documentation, visual storytelling, and economic analysis, it then shows how decades of water exports to Front Range cities, including Colorado Springs and Aurora, have fundamentally changed the Valley and continue to affect its agricultural economy and communities today.

More than 100,000 acres of historically irrigated farmland have been dried up across the five-county Lower Arkansas Valley. This includes over 40,000 acres permanently dried up due to water exports to cities on the Front Range. Economic modeling commissioned by the Lower Ark District estimates that the overall loss of irrigated agriculture has reduced the region’s economic output by approximately $142 million every year, including $52 million annually in Crowley County alone.

The StoryMap also identifies approximately 40,000 additional irrigated acres at high risk of permanent dry-up. If those lands are dried up, the economic modeling estimates that the lost economic output in the Lower Arkansas Valley could increase to $184 million each year.

The economic findings in the StoryMap were derived from analyses performed using the Lower Arkansas Valley (LAV) Explorer, developed for and licensed to the Lower Ark District by The Freshwater Trust using its patented BasinScout® modeling platform. The LAV Explorer quantifies the direct and secondary economic impacts of irrigated farmland dry-up and estimates the potential impacts of future water transfers.

 

For more information on data sources and methods, visit the StoryMap’s resources page.

The findings are intended to inform decision-making by elected officials, policymakers, and the public as Colorado considers the long-term implications of agricultural-to-municipal water exports. The StoryMap also calls for new policies, programs, and trusted partnerships that make it economically viable for farmers to continue farming and keep their water in the Valley.

“When irrigation water is permanently exported from the Lower Arkansas Valley to far-away cities, Colorado isn’t simply moving water. It’s also moving economic opportunity away from the communities that have long depended on it. For rural communities like ours, far from major population centers, that lost economic activity has proven extremely difficult to replace,” said Jack Goble, General Manager, Lower Ark District. “One community should not be sacrificed for the growth of another. Colorado should not grow its cities by drying up the agricultural communities that feed them. The future of the Lower Arkansas Valley will not be determined by chance. It will be determined by the choices we make.”

The StoryMap was introduced at the Lower Arkansas Valley Water Summit on Nov. 4 in Rocky Ford, which drew nearly 200 attendees from across southeast Colorado and the state. The Summit brought together agricultural producers, business and community leaders, state legislators and other elected officials, and residents. The event provided an opportunity for attendees to better understand the consequences of agricultural water exports and discuss the region’s water future.

“Understanding the impacts of water exports is imperative to statewide planning and policymaking, especially for communities adversely impacted by these actions. The ability to assess economic impact allows communities to make informed, data-driven decisions,” stated Scott Campbell, Senior Strategic Consultant for the Upper Colorado River Basin, The Freshwater Trust. “It is only by reflecting on the actions of the past can we better shape our futures.”

To view the StoryMap, visit: whenwaterleaves.com

About the Lower Arkansas Valley Water Conservancy District
Since 2002, the Lower Arkansas Valley Water Conservancy District has served Pueblo, Crowley, Otero, Bent, and Prowers counties with a focus on safeguarding water resources in the Lower Arkansas Valley for current and future generations. www.lowerark.com

About The Freshwater Trust
The Freshwater Trust is a non-governmental organization that works to protect and restore freshwater ecosystems. Engaging with cities, industry, and agriculture, The Freshwater Trust uses advanced technologies to produce the insights people need to solve problems at the intersection of water and the economy. The Freshwater Trust uses its technology to guide policy and inform watershed funding and finance decisions—helping communities build the solutions they need to solve complex water problems. www.thefreshwatertrust.org

Readers can visit the Lower Ark Valley’s website to sign up for their newsletters.  The link is at the bottom of the home page on the website.

#    #    #

By: Barbara Crimond

Filed Under: Agriculture • County • Environment • Featured • Hot Topics • Media Release • The Journal Alert

About the Author: