
State Rep. Lorena Garcia, D-Adams County, helps Ken Barber sign a petition to get a graduated income tax initative on the November 2026 ballot at Del Mar Park in Aurora, Colorado, on Monday, July 27, 2026. (Jesse Paul, The Colorado Sun)
Article by Taylor Dolven, TheColorado Sun
- Share – Hit control+click to go to full article
It’s a familiar threat from millionaires and big business: If you increase our taxes, we’ll leave the state. And it’s become a central argument for the campaign against Amendment 87, which, if approved by voters in November, would reduce the income tax rate for individuals and businesses in Colorado making less than about $500,000 and raise it for those earning more to generate an estimated $2 billion in its first year for education, childcare and healthcare.
“When taxes go up, big businesses leave and take their good-paying jobs with them,” Michael Smith, the state director of the National Federation of Independent Business, said in a statement. NFIB, like other major Colorado business groups, is campaigning against the ballot measure with radio and television ads.
But the reality is not so simple.
As the campaigns for and against Amendment 87 reach their fever pitch ahead of the Nov. 3 election, experiences from other states with graduated income tax systems show the doomsday departures are overstated. Yes, some rich people leave to avoid higher taxes. But, overwhelmingly, millionaires stay put.
In Massachusetts, where voters increased income taxes on earnings over $1 million to 9% from 5% in 2022, the mass exodus of wealthy residents tax critics predicted did not materialize. From 2022 to 2023, nearly 30,000 more people left Massachusetts than moved in, according to a Boston Globe analysis of the most recent Internal Revenue Service data, one of the highest rates of outmigration in the country. But more than 70% of the net loss in population came from people making less than $200,000 a year. And the tax hike has raised far more revenue from the wealthy than estimated.
Doomsday downfall averted
Massachusetts, like Colorado, had a flat income tax in its constitution — meaning everyone was taxed at the same rate regardless of their earnings — before approving what is widely known as the “millionaire’s tax.” Massachusetts’ flat tax rate had been 5%. Colorado’s is currently 4.4%. Massachusetts now has two personal income tax brackets: Those who make less than $1 million a year owe 5% and those who make more owe 9%. The state has a corporate income tax of 8%.
Amendment 87 would create six income tax brackets in Colorado starting at a rate of 3.7% for earnings up to $25,000 and climbing to 8.4% for income above $1 million. The change would apply to both individual taxpayers and businesses.
The proposed graduated rates apply to federal taxable income as determined by Section 63 of the Internal Revenue Code, for tax years beginning on or after Jan. 1, 2027. Brackets: 3.7% up to $25,000; 4.2% to $100,000; 4.4% to $500,000; 7.4% to $750,000; 7.9% to $1M; 8.4% above $1M. “Current” reflects Colorado’s 4.40% flat rate. Estimate only; individual filings vary.
The tax brackets under Amendment 87
If approved by voters, Amendment 87 would replace the state’s 4.4% flat income tax rate with a graduated system whose tax rates rise with income. The new brackets would apply to individuals and businesses.
| Income Bracket |
Current Tax Rate |
Amendment 87 Tax Rate |
| $25,000 or less |
4.4% |
3.7% |
| $25,001 to $100,000 |
4.4% |
4.2% |
| $100,001 to $500,000 |
4.4% |
4.4% |
| $500,001 to $750,000 |
4.4% |
7.4% |
| $750,001 to $1,000,000 |
4.4% |
7.9% |
| More than $1,000,000 |
4.4% |
8.4% |
Source: Colorado Legislative Council Staff
Those who make under about $500,000 annually — about 97% of Colorado taxpayers, according to nonpartisan legislative analysts — would pay less than they do now by a few hundred dollars. Those making more than about $500,000 — about 100,000 taxpayers — would pay more. An individual or business earning $1 million would pay about $16,000 more.
Cristobal Young, an associate sociology professor at Cornell University who studies tax-driven migration, said individual income tax increases in other states did not lead to widespread exoduses. He has studied tax changes for the rich in New Jersey, which has a 10.75% personal income tax rate for earnings above $1 million, New York, which has 10.9% for earnings over $25 million, and California, which has 13.3% for earnings over $1 million.
“The tax flight story is empowering for people who feel that they can wield it: ‘I’m taking what’s mine and I’m leaving and you’ll be sorry when I’m gone’,” Young said. “But when you get down to the reality of tax migration, moving to another state is the most difficult of all things you can contemplate to reduce your tax burden.”
Studies show increases in corporate taxes affect business decisions about where to locate and whether to grow, but widespread closures and relocations are unlikely. Jim Rooney, president and CEO of the Boston Chamber of Commerce, campaigned against the millionaire’s tax in Massachusetts because he was worried it would be a drain on the state’s economy and cause talented people to leave. Now, four years later, Rooney said it’s too soon to tell what the total impact on the business climate of the state has been. What the IRS data doesn’t show, Rooney said, is how many people decided not to move to Massachusetts because of the tax.
Instead of trying to repeal the tax, which Rooney suspects would be unsuccessful, he has tried to influence how the money is spent. Revenue from the tax has blown far past projections. Proponents estimated it would generate $2 billion each year. Last fiscal year, it brought in $3 billion and this year it is on track to bring in even more.
With the additional revenue, Massachusetts has expanded childcare subsidies to 18,500 low-I come families, made community college free, provided free meals for K-12 students, eliminated fares on many buses and chipped away at an enormous backlog of repairs to roads, bridges and train tracks across the state. “One could ask the question, ‘But for this tax would we be able to do those things?’” Rooney said. “There have been some good things that have happened.”
If passed, Amendment 87 would channel the money it raises to healthcare and education, Colorado’s two biggest expenses, as well as childcare. Facing budget shortfalls of more than $1 billion over the past two years, Colorado lawmakers have made cuts to Medicaid, affecting children with disabilities, and failed to sustain the state’s crumbling childcare system.
The Denver Metro Chamber of Commerce is opposing Amendment 87, saying, “The massive $2+ billion annual tax increase would make it more expensive for our local Main Street businesses to create jobs, operate and grow.” One Denver tax attorney who has wealthy clients told The Colorado Sun that some of her clients are already working to reduce their tax burdens in Colorado ahead of the election by changing their addresses, driver’s licenses and voting registrations to Florida.
Proponents of the initiative say Colorado is out of options. “We’re either going to cut healthcare for older adults or we’re going to bring in new revenue,” said Chris deGruy Kennedy, president and CEO of the Bell Policy Center, which is backing the amendment. “We can do that by raising everyone’s taxes or raising the taxes of those who can afford to pay more.”
Conservatives, however, argue that the state already spends too much on healthcare. And they say that raising taxes on businesses will increase costs for everyone at a time when prices are already high. Mark LeValley, president of the Colorado Cattlemen’s Association, said in a statement that ranchers already face huge financial pressures from drought, high gas prices and shifting tariff policies. “Now is not the time to drag these small businesses down any further,” he said.
The fate of the state’s tax system will come down to voters.
# # #